| Doctors
take up the `practice' of business
 Today
MBA classrooms are filled with a variety of people
from all walks of life - including doctors. It
isn't unusual to find a few physicians among the
pupils, with their beepers at their sides, ready
to exit class early in case of an emergency. Other
students may wonder why a doctor would need or
want a Master's in Business Administration, but
with the increasing complexity of the healthcare
industry, many physicians find that there is more
to their jobs than just practicing medicine. What
doctors are discovering is that an MBA enables
them to be better prepared to make management
decisions and face the many business challenges
that arise in healthcare.
"Physicians
have always gotten a bad rap as poor businesspeople,"
says Douglas E. Hough, Ph.D., director of the
business medical programs with Johns Hopkins University,
Columbia, Md. "Over the past 10 years more and
more physicians have had the opportunity to run
businesses through solo and group practices."
Johns Hopkins University is just one of many schools
that is seeing a growing number of physicians
enter the MBA program. Since 1994 the school has
offered a four-year course certification program
to physicians; since 1999 they have offered an
MBA program. So far, 275 students have earned
certificates, 50 have earned MBAs and 85 more
are working toward their degrees.
Physicians
are needed as leaders in the development and management
of healthcare facilities; biotechnology-focused
industries, health insurance/managed care firms
and pharmaceutical, medical supply and medical
equipment companies. According to Joan E. Shook,
M.D., director of the Baylor College of Medicine/Rice
University, Jesse H. Jones School of Management
MD/MBA programs, people enter the program for
several different reasons. Through this program
students spend five years to earn both an M.D.
and an MBA. "These young students are drawn to
the program because they believe that the combination
of the two skills sets will allow them greater
freedom and flexibility when they enter the job
market," Dr. Shook says. Some students have strong
leadership skills and think that they will enter
leadership positions in medical schools, physician
groups, hospitals or managed care organizations.
"Most of these people are in a leadership position
and feel that they need more business skills in
order to make their enterprise successful or they
are frustrated by their current position and seek
a career change," she says. "A few of the people
that I have spoken to are entrepreneurs at heart
and are seeking the skills to bring their innovations
to market."
What
do physicians need to become better managers?
A basic set of skills for doctor-managers would
include accounting, budgeting, human resource
management, strategic planning and perhaps marketing,
negotiation, communication and organizational
theory. However, physicians need to know more
than marketing and finance; they need to be familiar
with both the practices and theories of managed
care and how to manage the health of the population.
Working
in the anesthesiology department at Children's
Hospital in Columbus, Ohio, Russell Sauder, M.D.,
decided he needed to get his MBA in order to not
only negotiate with businesspeople but to learn
what it would take to start his own practice.
He is currently enrolled in the MBA program at
Capital University in Columbus. "I had no background
in finance and accounting," Dr. Sauder explains.
"I wanted to stay in medicine but know how to
talk business." Due to the complexities of managed
care, Dr. Sauder knew he had to understand how
to deal with medicine as a business. "If someone
throws a balance sheet in front of me I need to
understand all about cost and revenue."
Dr.
Sauder admits that when he started the program
he wanted to learn how to be a better businessman,
but now he is actually considering starting his
own business. "This just reflects the different
generations," he notes. "Our parents worked with
one company their whole lives, but we need changes."
Even doctors need choices. Steven Meltzer, M.D.,
MBA, received his medical degree from the University
of Southern California in 1981. He served a pediatric
residency at Children's Hospital of Los Angeles
from 1981 to 1984 and then fellowship in allergy/immunology
at Kaiser Foundation Hospital in Los Angeles from
1984 through 1986. "While at Kaiser, it became
apparent that managed care was going in a direction
that doctors were going to either be the `managers'
or the `managees,' " Dr. Meltzer says. With this
understanding, he entered the MBA program at Cal
State Long Beach in the fall of 1986. He joined
an allergy private practice in Long Beach, Calif.,
on a part-time basis while pursuing the degree.
It
took Dr. Meltzer six years to attain his degree,
taking two courses each semester and at least
one summer course. He says the reason it took
him so long was the prerequisites needed for graduate
business classes. "Nevertheless, it was beneficial
to be exposed to other MBA students in different
industries as I could appreciate the insulation
of the healthcare field that so many of us take
for granted," he says.
Because
he was just starting his practice when he went
to school, his patient load didn't affect his
studies. He felt it was somewhat of an advantage
to be in school while starting a practice because
the lessons could be more quickly applied. "My
business professors were usually considerate of
my professional obligations but not always," he
explains. "In some respects, some of the faculty
seemed to be challenged in a positive manner by
my presence in their classes. Some of the professors
had definite misconceptions regarding physicians
and hospitals, so I felt compelled to provide
some education to them in return."
Initially,
he had planned to become a financial planner for
physicians, but unfortunately he did not like
the difficulties of dealing with physicians and
their money. "I was more attracted to marketing,
more specifically patient and physician behaviors
with respect to advertising for the pharmaceutical
industry," he explains. "This has helped greatly
in building my practice as well as consulting
activities for pharmaceutical companies. Most
importantly, it made me a better physician in
understanding my patients' needs and wants."
For
Dr. Meltzer the most important lesson from business
school is the ability to think strategically.
"Many physicians and healthcare concerns have
a very short-sighted viewpoint. Taking into account
internal and external factors over a three- to
five-year horizon provides immense benefits to
planning a career and the tools needed for success,"
he notes. "Over time, my practice has grown exponentially
while maintaining the commitment to provide quality
healthcare."
Unfortunately,
most MBA programs have been designed for full-time
students or professionals with schedules that
are not as demanding as a physician's schedule.
"I've had physicians who were paged and had to
leave in the middle of class," Dr. Hough says.
"We do whatever we can to accommodate." One school
that has certainly made an effort to accommodate
doctors is Denver-based Regis University. The
school has just started to offer the very first
online MBA program designed specifically for physicians.
The program is available to doctors via the Internet
24 hours a day, seven days a week. The added benefit
is that no classroom attendance is ever required.
"We wanted to reach out to people who, for whatever
reason, cannot attain the degree in class," says
Michael Goess, chairperson of the university's
MBA program. "So far it is working out very well;
the physicians like it."
Doctors
who participate in the program earn Continuing
Medical Education Category 1 credit toward the
AMA Physicians Recognition Award. A maximum of
121 credits can be earned for the complete degree
program, which includes a total of 12 courses.
According to Goess, videos in which professors
discuss different topics are provided to the students.
Also, class discussions are held through the bulletin
board and students can ask their professors questions
through a chat room.
Physicians
are trained in medical school to be in charge
of the patient and not be concerned with the costs
for care. However, they need to start thinking
like businesspeople: Which costs reports should
the accountant do? Finding a better way to negotiate
a managed care contract. With the growing complexities
of the healthcare industry, doctors who can relate
to both the medical and business sides of the
sector will undoubtedly enhance the lives of all
who depend on their care. - SHERRI PFEIL,
Staff Writer

|
| |
|
|
|